Being a fairly politically active Libertarian Indian-American. I have some perspective to offer.
The thing about respect is correct but this "lack of respect" translates into real world experiences that snowball. For example a lot of Indian friends have reported being abused in parking lot by MAGA hat wearing people. Their kids being abused in school. A hard core MAGA friend's mother was detained at the airport despite having greencard (she had it for 20+ years) they thought the reason she is not naturalizing is because she might have some crimes. This 75+ lady was deeply traumatized by the whole experience. Her son turned full on Democrat.
The problem with these personal experiences is that once you have gone through one such experience, there is no amount showmanship, tax cuts or glorious speeches is gonna turn you a Republican.
These things generally do not show up in surveys and when you talk to people. But at the back of their mind these experiences play a bigger role than anything else.
Nobody considers Indians "Asian ' anymore than Russians, Arabs, or Filipinos my friend. Your point is valid and I think Brian was hinting at it as well but let's not try and lump Indians and Japanese together.
I hear your story and agree it resounds with many people but kids being bullied in school is just called school, their peers wearing MAGA hats, if they were, were the modern edgelord punk equivalent of 80's kids wearing swastikas. If they weren't Indian they would have gotten picked on for being fat, if they were the star quarterback, nobody would have picked on them even if Indian, I.e. losers get bullied in school regardless of what feature is being being called out because, well losers.
Likewise I just can't genuinely imagine completely unprovoked sober random middle-class white men with their family's in the middle of a Costco parking lot routinely just walk up to random Indian people and "abuse" them because honestly, most people just can't be bother or are passive aggressive, not aggressive aggressive. When I hear those stories I generally think variants of BS, "I knew a guy", provoked, drunk, or wrong side of the tracks. I mean I've been racially "abused" myself in public but rarely has it been completely random. Generally US racism is passive aggressive in my experience, not open, at least outside the aforementioned categories.
My counterexample is I have Nepalese family members, whom most people just assume are Indians on initial meet, that grew up in America in a wealthy, nearly all white, Great Lakes suburbs. They are well adjusted socially and neither they nor their parents have every complained about their neighbors holding their ethnicity against them, at least outside the examples I give such as a drunk black guy in the ghetto pissed you wouldn't holla'back at him.
Too long a comment. Please make you point with text that does not require me an LLM to parse.
It is irrelevant that you want to gaslight things here claim "I do not believe", "bulling is just bulling" etc. but individuals at the receiving end do not.
Also, it is objectively true that vast majority Americans of course are not racist. All it takes is one encounter with the MAGA underclass for people to associate negative sentiments with Republicans.
I don't disagree with their perception, people are great at ascribing motives to others where none exists to avoid blaming themselves. What I doubt though generally is the stories even happened most of the time. In my experience everyone "knows someone who was racially abused" while never having experienced it themselves. In reality it happened once maybe to someone one time somewhere in history and now everyone "knows that guy", like smallpox blankets.
Like where exactly are your Indian friends hanging out? To quote a Filipino friend of mine "If you don't like being called a haole, don't hangout and drink with poor trashy Filipinos in the dive bar in the Filipino ghetto". Where magically are all these Indians in droves hanging out in rural trailer parks in Arkansas smoking meth?
It really takes just one encounter over 10 years to have an impact, when the Democrats are saying over and over that you are discriminated against. And if each Indian has 1 insult shouted every 10 years and 5 of them get together, they have a lot of evidence. THen, every other slight gets attriuted to that, as well as their missed promotions, etc.
> In my experience everyone "knows someone who was racially abused" while never having experienced it themselves
Again this is gaslighting and illogical at that. I can for example precisely tell you my encounters with MAGA underclass. But I am not a Democrat so it would not matter much to this specific decision. A more interesting data point is where people switched on from full blown Republican to Democrat over time.
> In reality it happened once maybe to someone one time somewhere in history and now everyone "knows that guy", like smallpox blankets.
That claim can be used to dismiss any data point that is not methodical and not peer reviewed. You claim "people are great at ascribing motives to others where none exists to avoid blaming themselve" falls into the same category. But it even moronic because there is "blame" here. It is all about people changing their political orientation over time. There is nothing to "blame" anyone here.
> Where magically are all these Indians in droves hanging out in rural trailer parks in Arkansas smoking meth?
I am not even sure what it means or how it is relevant to anything we are discussing here.
It did play a big role in shifting a lot of Asian votes to GOP. But Harvard saying we do not want you here is different from rest of the society saying we do not want you here.
I think you also need to consider that nowadays, elites like academics and journalists overwhelmingly support the Democratic Party. Who do you think newcomers (especially ones who value higher education) will choose to align themselves with - the elites or the proles?
I think this hypothesis is basically putting a more positive/charitable spin on the social science finding that White leftists are the only ethno-political subgroup with negative in-group preference across all races, which a right-winger might interpret more negatively (i.e. as suggesting that there is something fundamentally wrong with White leftists).
It is true that the average White Republican will not be thrilled by “women in saris or statues of Ganesha, or [hearing] about arranged marriages and great Indian restaurants,“ and will be unwilling to elevate that culture above his own, even just rhetorically (the Lake Wobegon effect you mention). By contrast, because White leftists have a self-deprecating view of their race and culture, they honestly think that other cultures are superior to their own. Thus, they will invariably do a better job of flattering outsiders than White right-wingers who retain some baseline degree of cultural chauvinism and are fundamentally just pretending.
Like I said, though, I don’t think this is some unique property of White right-wingers, since I can’t imagine a party in India or Japan catering to British expats by going on about how fish and chips is so much better than bland Japanese food and how the English suit is so much more fashionable and refined than the garish Sari. It is the White leftist who is unique in his lack of self-esteem, and whether that is a good thing or a bad thing depends on your point of view.
100% IME. East Asians are 100% a fit for the nominal stereotypical Republican as they are highly conservative, pro traditional values, pro gun, pro business, anti immigration, racist ASF, and extremely pro veneer yet none of them would be caught voting Republican, cue Hawaii which is more conservative than Alabama but effectively 0% Republican.
This seems self evidently true. Minorities of all stripes vote Dem because of recognition (MAGA exists for the same reason just for non-college educated white people). Fukuyama was writing about this in the 90s.
Bo’s tweet was definitely in poor taste and will seriously hurt Republican performance among Indians (at least in Texas), but these trends of Asians and Indians voting left (and more broadly holding more left-wing views on specific issues) have been around before Bo or even Trump himself. I wasn’t personally able to find a single midterm or presidential election where Indians voted majority for the Right, and neither could ChatGPT. So even though Bo’s tweet was crude and has a taste of ethnic resentment, I don’t think its correct to say that Asian or Indian left-wing voting patterns are caused by modern right-wing animus. If anything, I think the animus towards Indians on the right is driven in party by those very same left-wing voting patterns. Of course there are also feelings of resentment at Indians outperforming Whites academically, baseline ethnocentrism, etc. which I think critics of Bo are correct to point out.
Brian,
Being a fairly politically active Libertarian Indian-American. I have some perspective to offer.
The thing about respect is correct but this "lack of respect" translates into real world experiences that snowball. For example a lot of Indian friends have reported being abused in parking lot by MAGA hat wearing people. Their kids being abused in school. A hard core MAGA friend's mother was detained at the airport despite having greencard (she had it for 20+ years) they thought the reason she is not naturalizing is because she might have some crimes. This 75+ lady was deeply traumatized by the whole experience. Her son turned full on Democrat.
The problem with these personal experiences is that once you have gone through one such experience, there is no amount showmanship, tax cuts or glorious speeches is gonna turn you a Republican.
These things generally do not show up in surveys and when you talk to people. But at the back of their mind these experiences play a bigger role than anything else.
Nobody considers Indians "Asian ' anymore than Russians, Arabs, or Filipinos my friend. Your point is valid and I think Brian was hinting at it as well but let's not try and lump Indians and Japanese together.
I hear your story and agree it resounds with many people but kids being bullied in school is just called school, their peers wearing MAGA hats, if they were, were the modern edgelord punk equivalent of 80's kids wearing swastikas. If they weren't Indian they would have gotten picked on for being fat, if they were the star quarterback, nobody would have picked on them even if Indian, I.e. losers get bullied in school regardless of what feature is being being called out because, well losers.
Likewise I just can't genuinely imagine completely unprovoked sober random middle-class white men with their family's in the middle of a Costco parking lot routinely just walk up to random Indian people and "abuse" them because honestly, most people just can't be bother or are passive aggressive, not aggressive aggressive. When I hear those stories I generally think variants of BS, "I knew a guy", provoked, drunk, or wrong side of the tracks. I mean I've been racially "abused" myself in public but rarely has it been completely random. Generally US racism is passive aggressive in my experience, not open, at least outside the aforementioned categories.
My counterexample is I have Nepalese family members, whom most people just assume are Indians on initial meet, that grew up in America in a wealthy, nearly all white, Great Lakes suburbs. They are well adjusted socially and neither they nor their parents have every complained about their neighbors holding their ethnicity against them, at least outside the examples I give such as a drunk black guy in the ghetto pissed you wouldn't holla'back at him.
Too long a comment. Please make you point with text that does not require me an LLM to parse.
It is irrelevant that you want to gaslight things here claim "I do not believe", "bulling is just bulling" etc. but individuals at the receiving end do not.
Also, it is objectively true that vast majority Americans of course are not racist. All it takes is one encounter with the MAGA underclass for people to associate negative sentiments with Republicans.
I don't disagree with their perception, people are great at ascribing motives to others where none exists to avoid blaming themselves. What I doubt though generally is the stories even happened most of the time. In my experience everyone "knows someone who was racially abused" while never having experienced it themselves. In reality it happened once maybe to someone one time somewhere in history and now everyone "knows that guy", like smallpox blankets.
Like where exactly are your Indian friends hanging out? To quote a Filipino friend of mine "If you don't like being called a haole, don't hangout and drink with poor trashy Filipinos in the dive bar in the Filipino ghetto". Where magically are all these Indians in droves hanging out in rural trailer parks in Arkansas smoking meth?
It really takes just one encounter over 10 years to have an impact, when the Democrats are saying over and over that you are discriminated against. And if each Indian has 1 insult shouted every 10 years and 5 of them get together, they have a lot of evidence. THen, every other slight gets attriuted to that, as well as their missed promotions, etc.
> In my experience everyone "knows someone who was racially abused" while never having experienced it themselves
Again this is gaslighting and illogical at that. I can for example precisely tell you my encounters with MAGA underclass. But I am not a Democrat so it would not matter much to this specific decision. A more interesting data point is where people switched on from full blown Republican to Democrat over time.
> In reality it happened once maybe to someone one time somewhere in history and now everyone "knows that guy", like smallpox blankets.
That claim can be used to dismiss any data point that is not methodical and not peer reviewed. You claim "people are great at ascribing motives to others where none exists to avoid blaming themselve" falls into the same category. But it even moronic because there is "blame" here. It is all about people changing their political orientation over time. There is nothing to "blame" anyone here.
> Where magically are all these Indians in droves hanging out in rural trailer parks in Arkansas smoking meth?
I am not even sure what it means or how it is relevant to anything we are discussing here.
I wonder why the efforts to disadvantage Asians in school admissions and hiring are not perceived as a lack of respect…
It did play a big role in shifting a lot of Asian votes to GOP. But Harvard saying we do not want you here is different from rest of the society saying we do not want you here.
I think you also need to consider that nowadays, elites like academics and journalists overwhelmingly support the Democratic Party. Who do you think newcomers (especially ones who value higher education) will choose to align themselves with - the elites or the proles?
The survey data is almost 20 years old, a generation out of date. Is there nothing more recent?
The article is 13 years old!
I think this hypothesis is basically putting a more positive/charitable spin on the social science finding that White leftists are the only ethno-political subgroup with negative in-group preference across all races, which a right-winger might interpret more negatively (i.e. as suggesting that there is something fundamentally wrong with White leftists).
It is true that the average White Republican will not be thrilled by “women in saris or statues of Ganesha, or [hearing] about arranged marriages and great Indian restaurants,“ and will be unwilling to elevate that culture above his own, even just rhetorically (the Lake Wobegon effect you mention). By contrast, because White leftists have a self-deprecating view of their race and culture, they honestly think that other cultures are superior to their own. Thus, they will invariably do a better job of flattering outsiders than White right-wingers who retain some baseline degree of cultural chauvinism and are fundamentally just pretending.
Like I said, though, I don’t think this is some unique property of White right-wingers, since I can’t imagine a party in India or Japan catering to British expats by going on about how fish and chips is so much better than bland Japanese food and how the English suit is so much more fashionable and refined than the garish Sari. It is the White leftist who is unique in his lack of self-esteem, and whether that is a good thing or a bad thing depends on your point of view.
100% IME. East Asians are 100% a fit for the nominal stereotypical Republican as they are highly conservative, pro traditional values, pro gun, pro business, anti immigration, racist ASF, and extremely pro veneer yet none of them would be caught voting Republican, cue Hawaii which is more conservative than Alabama but effectively 0% Republican.
This seems self evidently true. Minorities of all stripes vote Dem because of recognition (MAGA exists for the same reason just for non-college educated white people). Fukuyama was writing about this in the 90s.
There was obviously no way to account for a moron like Bo French when you wrote this.
Bo’s tweet was definitely in poor taste and will seriously hurt Republican performance among Indians (at least in Texas), but these trends of Asians and Indians voting left (and more broadly holding more left-wing views on specific issues) have been around before Bo or even Trump himself. I wasn’t personally able to find a single midterm or presidential election where Indians voted majority for the Right, and neither could ChatGPT. So even though Bo’s tweet was crude and has a taste of ethnic resentment, I don’t think its correct to say that Asian or Indian left-wing voting patterns are caused by modern right-wing animus. If anything, I think the animus towards Indians on the right is driven in party by those very same left-wing voting patterns. Of course there are also feelings of resentment at Indians outperforming Whites academically, baseline ethnocentrism, etc. which I think critics of Bo are correct to point out.