7 Comments
User's avatar
Jerry White's avatar

You say that "People vote for whoever respects them more."

Should that not be that "People vote for whoever they feel/think respects them more?"

It is my feeling that most politicians will attempt to gain the respect of the voter by saying (within limits) whatever is necessary to make the voter think that he/she respects them. I have watched many politicians change their campaign stump speech, again within limits, every time they give that speech to a different group. Now, with the 24 hour news cycle and 'social' media, every word a politician utters can be seen/heard within hours and is analyzed by commenters before the sound of the politicians voice fades into the ether..I am thinking that People vote, for the most part, for whoever tells them what they want to hear.

David R Henderson's avatar

I think you're right. How do we voters know who respects us more, or at all, if we don't know the politician?

JD's avatar

How do you differentiate tribal politics from ‘respects them more’?

Counter example: I had ai make me a chart comparing Republican vs Democrat donations from the military industry alongside sentiment towards military spending. Donations lean Republican generally, but counter-intuitively move Democrat when polls say “defense spending is too high.” Obama/Democrats actually got slightly more donations than McCain/Republicans from the defense industry in 2008 (‘spending too high’ polled very high), then far far less in 2012. How much effect was from the very negative sentiment towards defense spending in 2008? How much of the effect was due to McCain’s famous stance against pork? Or did Obama/democrats actually respect the defense industry more than McCain/Republicans in 2008 and not respect them in 2012?

Teamsters Union moved towards Trump in 2024; government unions certainly did not. How do you pull apart ‘respect’ from ‘policies that improve your bottom line’?

N Martin's avatar

Panders to us more accurate.

Daniel Melgar's avatar

I think this explains the MAGA crowd.

John Ketchum's avatar

I wonder whether the Respect Motive is a special case of a broader tribal motive. Humans evolved as group members, and much political behavior still seems organized around in-group identification and loyalty. A candidate can signal not only “I respect people like you,” but “I am one of you, I understand you, and I will defend people like us against people like them.” Perceived respect may therefore be one important signal of tribal alignment rather than the fundamental motive itself. That might also explain some apparent counterexamples to your model: when respect and tribal loyalty point in different directions, which one predicts the vote better?

Richard Bicker's avatar

Laughable. Machine politics and politicians have NO "respect" for voters (nameless unknown cogs in our electoral system). Does your car have more "respect" for your driving than that of your wife's? You're a silly man, Caplan.