More precisely, I agree that it’s fair enough re: those doomers with P(doom) north of 90%.
But it is perfectly rational that there are those with P(doom) in the range of 10% - 30% (over, say, the next 10-15 years) who would not take Brian’s shorter term bet nor go massively into debt.
A P(doom) of 10% is pretty significant and quite reasonably makes a strong case for policies one would not otherwise consider.
So it’s not that “This time is *definitely* different”.
It’s that this time it may well indeed be different,
Excellent summary. Also note that Andrew McAfee, a scientist at MIT and the cofounder of the Institute's Initiative on the Digital Economy and author of More From Less has made 14 bets on LongBets:
Kudos to you. Much respect for putting your $ where your mouth is. Far too often, prognosticators have no skin in their assertions, and suffer no loss (financial, reputational, or otherwise) for being wrong (even if repeatedly).
I was unaware there were such doomers in 2017.
I wonder if the landscape has changed now, and how a 2040 bet would play out.
I also wonder how a human superforecaster (à la Phil Tetlock’s research) would handicap such a bet today. (Although that timeline might be far too long for them to even attempt the analysis).
I would bet on it, too. Evolved human nature exaggerates the potential for bad, probably because bad events are deadlier than good events are helpful. There are many more words for negative emotions than positive emotions. But we need not rely on the amygdala when we have a cerebral cortex.
You forgot the Maya 2012 end of world
Most BC arguments are quite fair.
This one is not.
More precisely, I agree that it’s fair enough re: those doomers with P(doom) north of 90%.
But it is perfectly rational that there are those with P(doom) in the range of 10% - 30% (over, say, the next 10-15 years) who would not take Brian’s shorter term bet nor go massively into debt.
A P(doom) of 10% is pretty significant and quite reasonably makes a strong case for policies one would not otherwise consider.
So it’s not that “This time is *definitely* different”.
It’s that this time it may well indeed be different,
Excellent summary. Also note that Andrew McAfee, a scientist at MIT and the cofounder of the Institute's Initiative on the Digital Economy and author of More From Less has made 14 bets on LongBets:
https://longbets.org/user/amcafee/
Kudos to you. Much respect for putting your $ where your mouth is. Far too often, prognosticators have no skin in their assertions, and suffer no loss (financial, reputational, or otherwise) for being wrong (even if repeatedly).
I was unaware there were such doomers in 2017.
I wonder if the landscape has changed now, and how a 2040 bet would play out.
I also wonder how a human superforecaster (à la Phil Tetlock’s research) would handicap such a bet today. (Although that timeline might be far too long for them to even attempt the analysis).
I would bet on it, too. Evolved human nature exaggerates the potential for bad, probably because bad events are deadlier than good events are helpful. There are many more words for negative emotions than positive emotions. But we need not rely on the amygdala when we have a cerebral cortex.