14 Comments
User's avatar
James Hanley's avatar

"Conspicuously absent from the list of possible causes is the default explanation....namely: On average, men enjoy editing Wikipedia much more than women do"

I would note that the list of possible causes includes a number of explanations for *why* women might get less enjoyment from editing Wiki than men do. That is, your explanation is merely general, while the list gives *specific* explanations of your allegedly missing general explanation.

Those reasons for not getting as much enjoyment include:

- Aversion to conflict and an unwillingness to participate in lengthy edit wars.

- Belief that their contributions are too likely to be reverted or deleted.

- Some find its overall atmosphere misogynistic.

- Wikipedia culture is sexual in ways they find off-putting.

- Being addressed as male is off-putting to women whose primary language has grammatical gender.

- Fewer opportunities for social relationships and a welcoming tone compared to other sites.

Seriously, I know you like to be smugly more clever than everyone else, but it looks here like you didn't read, or if you read, you didn't think of the simple and obvious question, "What makes something enjoyable or not enjoyable."

FionnM's avatar

All of these explanations take for granted that women WOULD enjoy editing Wikipedia as much as men do, were it not for these obstacles placed in their way. I interpret Bryan to mean that, even if these obstacles were removed, women would still be underrepresented in Wikipedia, because women have systematically different interests from men.

James Hanley's avatar

But his explanation is *additional,* not alternative. The issue is about Wikipedia, so the specifics of Wikipedia culture are not irrelevant. Even if - which may be possible - women enjoy it less than men, those women who would otherwise enjoy it will enjoy it less because of the culture. Caplan oddly treats not enjoying that culture as irrelevant or not true or something like that. But that's stupid. It's as though he can't understand that misogyny might *also* affect women's enjoyment levels.

James Hanley's avatar

Look at it this way. Assume - just to have numbers - 5% of men and 3% of women enjoy writing Wiki articles. We'd obviously expect fewer by women.

But suppose also that women are more underrepresented than that, say they only write 1.5% of Wiki articles. Then that initial explanation is not fully explanatory.

But Caplan assumes it is and laughs that anyone even thinks more explanation than the initial explanation could be required.

Iceberg's avatar

Caplan's point is that no one is making the argument you've outlined, they are ignoring his "default explanation" entirely. If no one brings up the simplest explanation, it's likely that it is purposefully overlooked.

Also, I disagree that Wikepedia culture is relevant, because the same general speculations are made about any area where men greatly outnumber women. My experience is with chess-- "is chess culture misogynistic? Are chess clubs unfriendly to women?" etc.

Andrew's avatar

One trimester in my high school, students had the option of choosing what fiction topic they would read. One of the topics was called "technologies of power" and was about science fiction, and there were a few other topics people could choose too. Every single student who wound up in that class was male. This wasn't because of lack of female role models; in fact, the teacher who was running the course was a woman and passionate about the subject. There wasn't a big group of girls who were upset that they didn't get in either, and there were enough boys and girls talking to each other that I think I would have heard if there was.

Why are almost all science fiction readers, engineers, and programmers either men or trans women? I think it's the same reason girls tended not to enter that class. I wouldn't get that idea from the news though.

Joe Potts's avatar

Wikipedia and other online cultures (Stack Exchange) are highly exclusionary, regardless of gender, race, etc.

Geran Kostecki's avatar

A charitable explanation is that list is taking the default explanation as a given, and trying to figure out actionable ways to change it

Steve Cheung's avatar

Your default explanation for the gender disparity among editors sounds right. It’s not Wikipedia’s fault if there are simply more men interested and willing to put in the time to do the Wikipedia thing.

However, the gender disparity in the published biographies that are then proposed for deletion seems odd. More men interested in being editors by itself does not seem to account for why more female biographies would be deleted.

Robert Vroman's avatar

I feel a moral compulsion to correct any typo I notice on wikipedia.