11 Comments
User's avatar
Wes's avatar

I was unsure if I wanted kids. At ~31 i read your book and shared it with my then-girlfriend now wife. We decided we wanted a big family and number 4 is on the way

They are an absolute joy and I'm so happy you convinced me that the way other people parented is not how I need to do it. And that's been true!

Brett Powers's avatar

Had all my kids (7) by the time I found this book, but I agree wholeheartedly with it!

John A. Johnson's avatar

Your book came out 12 years after our fourth child was born, so I can't give you credit, but I do agree with most of the arguments in your book. Here's my story: From the time I was in high school through the birth of our second child, I was a proponent of zero population growth, planning to have no more than two children. But after our second child was born, my wife expressed a desire to have another. She said she always wanted three children. Obviously, we did not talk about the specific number of children we wanted before we got married. I grew up with two brothers, and I was always wary about the imbalance of the number 3. It seemed like there was always an odd brother out--usually the youngest--and I wanted to avoid that. With this in mind, and fully aware that the purpose of my life is to replicate my genes (I call myself a practicing Darwinian), I proposed to my wife that we have four children, and she agreed. There have been both joys and sorrows involving my children and grandchildren. I do not regret having four children. I would caution prospective parents, however, not to have children with the expectation for specific outcomes such as companionship, pride, and eventually grandchildren. As research indicates, we cannot control how our children will turn out. We need to be ready to accept whatever outcome emerges.

Leon Clark's avatar

I do supplementary homeschooling (because even at good schools the standards are so low) but your book taught me to accept that my kids are genetically constrained. I make sure that they can do the minimum in english and math and then we work on their strengths (writing for my 7 year old and math for my 10 year old. I also give my ten year old comprehension worksheets I had AI make on my favorite topics (econ, history of communism, WW2) to see if they provoke an interest and to give him basic knowledge that schools never will. So far, econ is a huge hit and he asks more about the other topics frequently.

I’d also like to share an observation about my own identical twins. They happen to be very different. Different mannerisms, very different voices and they have hit milestones many months apart. I expect their differences are largely due to IUGR when they were in the womb. Given that they are genetic clones these differences fall under nurture. I came to realize that even within “nurture” so much is dictated in the womb and very early development and I suspect is also caused by somewhat random epigenetic expressions (that is just a guess I’m not a scientist). My twins’ different personalities and mannerisms have been fixed since they were 1 or 2 (and possibly earlier, 1 or 2 is just when we recognized it) and no amount of pushing will change them. So even within nature’s share, I believe at least 50% is shaped so early that you can basically categorize it with genetics as outside your parental influence and control.

Richard Bicker's avatar

Keen observations here. Many people hear "genetic/environmental (nature/nurture)" and read into "environmental (nurture)" socialization, home/peer environment, and other sources of developmental influence. In fact, a great deal of the early "environment" that matters later in life is experienced in the womb and affects even (genetically) identical twins differently. Thus "environmental (nurture)" factors in human developments are more accurately termed simply "non-genetic" to cover the gamut.

Chris's avatar

I went from “probably not having any kids” to “actually having 2 kids” partly because of your book. I think I'm a pretty relaxed parent. Partly by nature but also tested by your book

Mark's avatar

I had my 5th child earlier this year. It's hard to disentangle the many influences in my life, but I was mindful of Caplan's ideas on parenting and especially bringing another potential future friend into the world when deciding to have my 4th and 5th child.

Ahem 🇵🇸🇨🇳🇰🇵🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈🦄's avatar

I was convinced kids would be manageable, but not fun to look after. Wife isn’t convinced and is concerned about the cost of childcare.

Nicolas Stefano Drpic's avatar

My question is whether it is outright useless to try to influence and improve one’s kid’s intelligence and a ademic performance through nurture. Should a parent give up in trying to make his/her kid better through, for example, things like reading to one’s kid everynight and things like that?

dqd's avatar
5hEdited

I only have a six months old daughter, so quantitatively, not yet. However, thanks to your writings, I realized that she is "my project" and not some kind of chore, which helped me to overcome hard times. Also, after reading your book, I am more inclined to have good quality time together without being afraid to spoil her. 🙂

Nathan Smith's avatar

I'm probably more relaxed as a parent based partly on your “parental irrelevantism” argument.