Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Reader's avatar

As someone who has struggled with alcohol addiction, I have to say that I think there isn’t always a bright line between can and can’t. My best analogy is to confession under torture. How should we judge someone’s claim that, “I couldn’t bear the torture any longer, so I confessed.” It seems like Bryan would have to say that this is false. What does it take to not confess? Just don’t open your mouth to speak and it’s done. Obviously, it’s reasonable in common parlance to say “can’t” when what one literally means is that the costs of doing something are so overwhelming that they choose not to do it. This is the experience of many people who struggle with addiction. It is obvious that we possess the physical capability to not consume a beverage. But the psychic costs of resisting a drink can often be so overwhelming that statements like “I couldn’t resist” feel justified (though of course they are literally false). I do think certain people who have never struggled with an addiction have a psychological blind spot when it comes to correctly assessing addicts’ actions and statements. For those who have never had the experience of addiction, a helpful empathy exercise can be to imagine how you would feel if you tried to resist eating any food or keep yourself in solitary confinement for a long period of time. The anguish you would feel along with the practically irresistible urge to break your fast or solitude is very similar to what many alcoholics feel when they try to stop drinking. That’s why many addicts describe their experiences attempting to get sober as hellish. They are not exaggerating. Hence, simplistic admonitions like, “just don’t drink alcohol,” are worse than useless. To know what it feels like to hear that as an alcoholic just imagine someone telling you “just never see or talk to another human again.” It’s not impossible, but it is a brutally painful way to live and some may legitimately prefer death.

Ze Shen's avatar

I feel like it mostly just boils down to how people use the word "can't". "He can't do the math" doesn't neessarily mean "he can't do the math no matter how much help he gets and how much effort he puts in", to me it means "he is unable to do the math given his current abilities" and it is not a statement of whether he will ever be able to do it.

8 more comments...

Ready for more?