6 Comments

Good piece. Nice to see Kirzner get some credit. I read Competition and Entrepreneurship... ouch, 42 years ago. "Speaking of Schumpeter—while he’s often contrasted with Kirzner, the empirical work suggests their insights are complementary." Yes, that seems right to me. Keep bridging the gap, Brian.

Expand full comment

It should be noted that Bob Murphy of the Mises Institute has also responded to some of Bryan's recent postings:

https://mises.org/podcasts/human-action-podcast/responding-bryan-caplans-continued-critique-austrians

Expand full comment

Gd

Expand full comment

Gd

Expand full comment

All this seems to me to overlook TWO elephants in the room.

The first elephant is shifting (thrashing) government regulations/laws.

The other is changing consumer tastes (demands).

With these two left out, how can the theories even have much power?

The first elephant was active indeed in Eastern Europe as central planning declined/fell away.

Expand full comment

Productivity is about satisfying consumer demands, not about tonnes of steel.

Expand full comment