Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Person Online's avatar

Open borders violate freedom of association in a very basic fashion. Even if you can get a majority of a nation's citizens to vote for it, you are in effect letting them vote to abolish the nation itself. This inflicts a fundamental violation upon any remaining citizens who would prefer not to see their nation abolished, as unless they carry dual-citizenship, they have no other homeland to retreat to.

Keith's avatar

As Noah Carl says, it all depends who the immigrants are. If they are skilled, well-educated, high achievers then they tend to be very good for the economy. If they are unskilled and low IQ then they tend to be very bad for both the economy and the culture of the receiving country. That is certainly the experience of Britain and most other western European countries. I'm curious as to how Bryan's interpretation of the data varies so wildly from that of people such as Emil Kirkegaard and Ed Dutton.

Of course one thing he didn't mention is the fact that the more diversity you get, the less social capital you get, a finding of the left-wing academic Robert Putnam. No doubt Bryan would say diversity only happens in the first generation of immigrants, after that their children integrate. I'd invite him to come to England and view the increasing number of Muslim women wearing the hijab. And of course if he's mainly talking about the children of immigrants then his argument that we don't have the financial burden of educating them is not valid: we actually DO educate the children of immigrants with resultant costs.

Evidence from Denmark suggests that at no point in their lives are immigrants from MENA countries beneficial to the economy, not even the period of their lives when they should be working, i.e. after their education costs have been paid and before they start receiving pensions.

All this apart, white Brits now constitute fewer than 30% of my hometown (when I was born 65 years ago it was 99%) and there is no noticeable slowing of support for welfare, nor is anyone other than a Labour (the welfare party) candidate voted into local office. The UK's GDP per capita has gone down as the GDP has remained stubbornly level, so mass immigration doesn't appear to have brought the economic benefits to Britain that Bryan is claiming. All that has really changed is that I now share my town with people who neither look, sound, nor behave like me. I certainly don't feel it's 'my town' anymore and am currently thinking up ways to escape the sheer ugliness of the place.

All Bryan's claims seem to rest on the assumption that the state won't be giving immigrants benefits, welfare cheques and free housing but that is not the world we live in, certainly not here in the caring sharing UK. Already a large proportion of the homeless on our streets are immigrants. Why would we allow more in to sleep rough on our streets and inevitably turn to crime to stay alive. Once they're here, it may be simply cheaper and less disruptive for society to give them all a house and welfare, of which there is already too little and too much respectively.

In short, Bryan's claim that 'immigration is good' is far too general a statement to be meaningful.

23 more comments...

Ready for more?