Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gerrit's avatar

Working with poor performers who nonetheless still get a paycheck is demotivating for the rest of the team. A drop in morale and productivity.

Doctor Hammer's avatar

Real world: I had an employee that should have been fired for poor performance years before I took over the team. The trouble was he was a nice guy just a total flake; one of my managers described him as a golden retriever puppy in fact. He rarely screwed up obviously and expensively enough to justify an instant firing, and since it was a small team transfering all his work to someone else was going to be miserable for all involved. We didn't have the ability to hire someone ahead of firing him to ease the workload transition, and dumping his entire workload one one or two other people was going to be a mess. He also had six kids and his wife didn't work (which was surprising considering he came across like a goofy kid and not a guy in his early 40's!) All that conspired to keep a guy who really needed to get his act together or get fired in a job.

My job on taking over the team was to go through his PIP (performance improvement plan) with an eye towards correcting the "needed to be fired a long time ago" problem. Thing was, he actually was improving so long as I was there to keep him focused, so it was going to be awkward.

As it turns out, I got into a conflict with a guy a few levels up from me who is definitely not "psychologically normal" and he fired me out of hand the next day, before the puppy got kicked. So far as I know, puppy is still working there.

I suspect that points to an interesting interaction effect between firing aversion (both individual and institutional) and the complete lack thereof mixed in the same company. Bad employees who are agreeable or otherwise keep their heads down will persist for a long time, but bad managers can also take out good employees, which obviates the benefits from being slow to fire people. You wind up with the worst of both worlds: it is slow to hire people and slow to get rid of poor performers as you grind through the HR process, and higher level employees that can get around the HR process will still do damage as they see fit.

Effects of firing aversion: Firing aversion tends to lead to large layoffs all at once, especially during generalized economic downturns. I have seen this in a few companies over the years, where companies hang on to poor performers out of firing aversion, then when there is a downturn in the news suddenly layoff a whole bunch of people at once. Happened in a company I was working for in 2008, as well as 2021, likewise 2024 due to business specific downturn and not general economic. Firing one person feels bad, and you have to explain that it is their fault for bad performance, but firing 10% of your workforce because of the market is outside your control and a lot easier to explain. Nothing personal, just the business, you are great but what can we do? We as economists would probably prefer that job turnover was more steady and smooth, but firing aversion means that when one person loses a job lots of people are, and when one firm is laying off lots of people other firms in the same industry are more likely to start dropping people as well. That no doubt makes finding the next job a lot harder as there is more competition for fewer roles.

14 more comments...

Ready for more?