I'm childless but currently under the impression that the optimal number of kids to have, from the kids' point of view, is two. In my opinion, I think one is okay, two is probably the best, and that anything more than two has a pretty high risk of creating a toxic environment between the siblings. My thinking is that with two, they either play together, fight with each other, or leave each other alone. But with three or more you start getting more convoluted social dynamics where one is bullied, excluded, etc. by the other two. I'm curious if you've seen this come up in research at all, or if you've seen the sibling dynamics play out in a way that makes you price that in at all.
Hi Bryan, I’m 24 and planning on having 3 kids with my soon to be fiancée starting next year, I’m excited by the prospect but I also still feel like a kid at times emotionally.
For instance, I can struggle with being too critical when I fail to meet expectations I set for myself. I can try to consciously remind myself to not do this, but it can slip through unconsciously and leak into interpersonal relationships as well.
Given that kids don’t know how to do anything right off the bat, I wouldn’t want to take this critical approach to them, as even if I didn’t say anything they would be able to read my expressions and internalise this critic.
Q: is attempting to “baby proof” my psychological sharp edges overkill, (I imagine that they wouldn’t have done this in the 1950’s), did you have any sharp edges when you had kids and how did you mellow them out (if you did…)?
1. I want as many kids as possible! However, I'm concerned that beyond a certain number, reduced individual attention starts significantly hurting children's happiness or relationships with their parents. At roughly what family size would you expect this to become a serious issue? Currently planning on 8.
2. Any thoughts on building a highly pronatalist culture within a close group of friends?
3. How can parents influence their children's lasting values, character, and worldview (internalised culture), if at all?
4. If you were an ambitious founder, would you prefer to have children in your early 20s at the same time as scaling or scale first and start later, say at 35-40?
Homeschooling: If one is not blessed with Caplan-twins, but barely average kids - should one homeschool a bare minimum of "intellectual skills" (math: +*/- and some % ; most people hardly can do those even few years out of K-12 school. Other topics? Reading, typing, AI and basic history/geography/economy/health. Windows office. And else let them get some practical skills: cooking, DIY, basic repair skills for house and car. How best to adapt the curriculum?
Parents should relax except in keen attention to what peer groups their children will have.
The thought is that peer influence might matter much more than parenting style does — and that parents might proactively influence peer-group exposure.
I completely buy your argument that long-term outcomes are heavily genetic and parents should relax. I'm actually considering having a third kid, but I'd like the immediate day-to-day experience of raising toddlers to be less exhausting.
What does the evidence show are the absolute best short- and medium-term techniques—maybe Gottman’s emotion coaching, for example—to minimize tantrums, enforce rules, and make the early childhood years genuinely more enjoyable? Looking at the research, which specific methods yield the best immediate ROI for parents' sanity? And are there any specific techniques that you feel are overlooked or underrated? "Techniques" could mean discipline, but it could mean things I haven't even considered! Very open on this.
Do you have any thoughts on robots helping to raise children? This is a serious question. A robot could theoretically push a baby cart or watch young children at a playground. Maybe with AI we’re close to robots being able to change a diaper. The cost would be the denial of human interaction but the gain would be lowering the cost of having children.
The book is targeted mainly at parents and would-be-parents, but after writing it, and just from being a parent, are there insights from research or pieces of advice you think would be especially valuable for those More Kids (and all kids) themselves to hear beyond the same message simply to be kept in mind for when they're older? Things that would have practical and immediate utility to them AS kids, students and such, being on the flip side of the picture.
When is it too late? In probate law sometimes reference is made to the “fertile octagenarian,” but I am asking about the parenting. Are there challenges facing an elderly father who conceives a late desire to raise two or three kids that make such a project impractical? Grandparents faced with raising very young children after a tragic loss of the parents are not in the same position: they have done it already, at least once, when they were younger. I am asking about an aging new parent thinking of doing it for the first time.
Why is it so hard to measure what is a "good" parent? My car insurance company knows if I'm a good driver. My doctor knows if I'm in good health. My bank knows if I have good credit. Is it because parenting is the thing that defines us the most and so we're afraid to be judged? Or how much can we separate who we are from the act of parenting?
Would you let parents sell equity in their newborn's future income to pay for raising them, as Robin suggests? You've worried about bankruptcy risk for adults selling their own future income. Is a baby who never consented different?
What about letting parents take debt on the name of children?
A question in Nicholas Decker logic: As you would have liked 4 more kids + your kids turned out so very well + your financial situation allows it: Why not try harder to have extra kids?
Obviously, your wonderful wife did admirably and is right to say: "I did my part." But there might be some prospective candidates willing to try. Even possible to combine it with opening borders (though the US only has an IR-5 parent visa for the mom if her US-child applies for it at 21 - crazily restrictive! Would not hold in the German constitutional court). But the kid(s) can have CRBA.
Bryan, Congrats on the new edition of the book! Q: Does "regression to the mean," from parents to offspring, in partly heritable traits that correlate with success in life (e.g., intelligence, conscientiousness), present special challenges for parents who are "high achievers"? Have you any practical pointers here?
I’ll get the obvious out of the way, which kid is your favorite?
The twins
Well, they are my fav.
I'm childless but currently under the impression that the optimal number of kids to have, from the kids' point of view, is two. In my opinion, I think one is okay, two is probably the best, and that anything more than two has a pretty high risk of creating a toxic environment between the siblings. My thinking is that with two, they either play together, fight with each other, or leave each other alone. But with three or more you start getting more convoluted social dynamics where one is bullied, excluded, etc. by the other two. I'm curious if you've seen this come up in research at all, or if you've seen the sibling dynamics play out in a way that makes you price that in at all.
Hi Bryan, I’m 24 and planning on having 3 kids with my soon to be fiancée starting next year, I’m excited by the prospect but I also still feel like a kid at times emotionally.
For instance, I can struggle with being too critical when I fail to meet expectations I set for myself. I can try to consciously remind myself to not do this, but it can slip through unconsciously and leak into interpersonal relationships as well.
Given that kids don’t know how to do anything right off the bat, I wouldn’t want to take this critical approach to them, as even if I didn’t say anything they would be able to read my expressions and internalise this critic.
Q: is attempting to “baby proof” my psychological sharp edges overkill, (I imagine that they wouldn’t have done this in the 1950’s), did you have any sharp edges when you had kids and how did you mellow them out (if you did…)?
What are your thoughts on David Bessis's theory on nature vs nurture? He seems to point out flaws with identical twin studies.
https://www.econtalk.org/nature-nurture-and-identical-twins-with-david-bessis/
1. I want as many kids as possible! However, I'm concerned that beyond a certain number, reduced individual attention starts significantly hurting children's happiness or relationships with their parents. At roughly what family size would you expect this to become a serious issue? Currently planning on 8.
2. Any thoughts on building a highly pronatalist culture within a close group of friends?
3. How can parents influence their children's lasting values, character, and worldview (internalised culture), if at all?
4. If you were an ambitious founder, would you prefer to have children in your early 20s at the same time as scaling or scale first and start later, say at 35-40?
Homeschooling: If one is not blessed with Caplan-twins, but barely average kids - should one homeschool a bare minimum of "intellectual skills" (math: +*/- and some % ; most people hardly can do those even few years out of K-12 school. Other topics? Reading, typing, AI and basic history/geography/economy/health. Windows office. And else let them get some practical skills: cooking, DIY, basic repair skills for house and car. How best to adapt the curriculum?
Bryan, True? Or False?:
Parents should relax except in keen attention to what peer groups their children will have.
The thought is that peer influence might matter much more than parenting style does — and that parents might proactively influence peer-group exposure.
What say you?
Could declining birth rate be a global existential risk ?
I completely buy your argument that long-term outcomes are heavily genetic and parents should relax. I'm actually considering having a third kid, but I'd like the immediate day-to-day experience of raising toddlers to be less exhausting.
What does the evidence show are the absolute best short- and medium-term techniques—maybe Gottman’s emotion coaching, for example—to minimize tantrums, enforce rules, and make the early childhood years genuinely more enjoyable? Looking at the research, which specific methods yield the best immediate ROI for parents' sanity? And are there any specific techniques that you feel are overlooked or underrated? "Techniques" could mean discipline, but it could mean things I haven't even considered! Very open on this.
Do you have any thoughts on robots helping to raise children? This is a serious question. A robot could theoretically push a baby cart or watch young children at a playground. Maybe with AI we’re close to robots being able to change a diaper. The cost would be the denial of human interaction but the gain would be lowering the cost of having children.
The book is targeted mainly at parents and would-be-parents, but after writing it, and just from being a parent, are there insights from research or pieces of advice you think would be especially valuable for those More Kids (and all kids) themselves to hear beyond the same message simply to be kept in mind for when they're older? Things that would have practical and immediate utility to them AS kids, students and such, being on the flip side of the picture.
When is it too late? In probate law sometimes reference is made to the “fertile octagenarian,” but I am asking about the parenting. Are there challenges facing an elderly father who conceives a late desire to raise two or three kids that make such a project impractical? Grandparents faced with raising very young children after a tragic loss of the parents are not in the same position: they have done it already, at least once, when they were younger. I am asking about an aging new parent thinking of doing it for the first time.
Why is it so hard to measure what is a "good" parent? My car insurance company knows if I'm a good driver. My doctor knows if I'm in good health. My bank knows if I have good credit. Is it because parenting is the thing that defines us the most and so we're afraid to be judged? Or how much can we separate who we are from the act of parenting?
Would you let parents sell equity in their newborn's future income to pay for raising them, as Robin suggests? You've worried about bankruptcy risk for adults selling their own future income. Is a baby who never consented different?
What about letting parents take debt on the name of children?
These the the ideas for increasing birth rate.
A question in Nicholas Decker logic: As you would have liked 4 more kids + your kids turned out so very well + your financial situation allows it: Why not try harder to have extra kids?
Obviously, your wonderful wife did admirably and is right to say: "I did my part." But there might be some prospective candidates willing to try. Even possible to combine it with opening borders (though the US only has an IR-5 parent visa for the mom if her US-child applies for it at 21 - crazily restrictive! Would not hold in the German constitutional court). But the kid(s) can have CRBA.
Bryan, Congrats on the new edition of the book! Q: Does "regression to the mean," from parents to offspring, in partly heritable traits that correlate with success in life (e.g., intelligence, conscientiousness), present special challenges for parents who are "high achievers"? Have you any practical pointers here?